Pilotenboard.de :: DLR-Test Infos, Ausbildung, Erfahrungsberichte :: operated by SkyTest® :: Foren-Übersicht

 Wiki  ChatChat  FAQFAQ   SuchenSuchen   MitgliederlisteMitgliederliste   BenutzergruppenBenutzergruppen 
 ProfilProfil   Einloggen, um private Nachrichten zu lesenEinloggen, um private Nachrichten zu lesen   LoginLogin   RegistrierenRegistrieren 

Besorgniserregende Zukunft f?r EFA-Studenten und LHG-Piloten
Gehe zu Seite Zurück  1, 2, 3  Weiter
 
Neues Thema eröffnen   Neue Antwort erstellen    Pilotenboard.de :: DLR-Test Infos, Ausbildung, Erfahrungsberichte :: operated by SkyTest® :: Foren-Übersicht -> Lufthansa-Ausbildung
Vorheriges Thema anzeigen :: Nächstes Thema anzeigen  
E92325
Captain
Captain


Anmeldungsdatum: 26.02.2024
Beiträge: 118

BeitragVerfasst am: Mo Dez 09, 2024 10:37 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

EASA seems close to allowing single pilot a350

Allowing something and executing it, are two different things. Anyway I cannot imagine, even, if it would be allowed.

Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

I'm not sure why EFA is not talking about this with new applicants or students.


Well, the flight students are the EFA's business case.

Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

Yeah, is it even worth trying to become a pilot anymore?


I would say, it depends on your aim. If you want to fly only for an flagcarrier, it think it is not, as it could be that you would never reach this goal. If you are ready to fly for other carriers e. g. Eurowings, Tui, etc. it is worth definitely.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
flapfail
Goldmember
Goldmember


Anmeldungsdatum: 23.03.2008
Beiträge: 6910
Wohnort: OGLE-2005-BLG-390Lb

BeitragVerfasst am: Mo Dez 09, 2024 1:15 pm    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

to be a commercial pilot is the best job ever

But under the present circumstances I would not do it again..... Rolling Eyes
_________________
**Happy landings**
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Mo Dez 09, 2024 6:10 pm    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

E92325 hat folgendes geschrieben:
Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

EASA seems close to allowing single pilot a350

Allowing something and executing it, are two different things. Anyway I cannot imagine, even, if it would be allowed.


I have to disagree. Keep in mind that airbus planed with a350 cockpit with signle pilot cruise in mind. EASA themselves said it is possible by 2027. Sure maybe they could be late, but its (probably but hopefully not) coming pretty soon. Same story for single pilot a321.

When I said "is it even worth it anymore" - my point was that being a pilot will be completely different in the future, and I think it will change in a way that most pilots don't like. Do we agree on that?
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Mo Dez 09, 2024 6:12 pm    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

flapfail hat folgendes geschrieben:
to be a commercial pilot is the best job ever

But under the present circumstances I would not do it again..... Rolling Eyes


Yeah, I hear that a lot. In the future, I'm not sure it will be the best job ever anymore. I guess this is just a consequence of technological progress. I'm so heavily conflicted. To start training or not to start training?
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
E92325
Captain
Captain


Anmeldungsdatum: 26.02.2024
Beiträge: 118

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 6:36 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

EASA themselves said it is possible by 2027


Yeah, i know what you mean and i understand you. But i do not believe it. We will see.

Flerq hat folgendes geschrieben:

To start training or not to start training?

If you have such worries, i think i does not make sense. To start the training with such worries, may propably have an negative impact on your training. The training should only be started, if you are absolutely conviced.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Laurens0404
Bruchpilot
Bruchpilot


Anmeldungsdatum: 29.10.2024
Beiträge: 5

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 11:10 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

I recently discussed the issue with a friend at Airbus and he said that it will be at least another 70 years before there are fully autonomous aircraft flying (and then only extremely few, as it is extremely expensive to insure). In addition, all existing aircraft would have to be converted and taken out of service... So when the first aircraft comes onto the market in 2028, for example, they will be ordered by the airlines (delivery takes
2-5 years) and they will need new training programs, which must be tested first.

In addition, extremely modern aircraft have been developed in the last 5 years, which can easily fly for 30 years.
Conversion would cost the airlines too much money.

The psychological aspect also plays a role; airlines and passengers have safety concerns about completely pilotless aircraft.

In my opinion, and the opinion of the engineer at Arirbus, autonomous aircraft will not fly for the next 60-80 years, or only in very isolated cases. In addition, 1-cockpit crews require an extremely high safety effort.

You can still become a pilot in our generation without hesitation.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 11:34 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

E92325 hat folgendes geschrieben:

If you have such worries, i think i does not make sense. To start the training with such worries, may propably have an negative impact on your training. The training should only be started, if you are absolutely conviced.


You have a good point. Sad part is, I've wanted this since I was four, and I flew my first plane at 12 during a intro flight. My issue is that these are coming, and probably quite soon as well. When they do eventually come, both eMCO and single pilot, I'm not sure I'll have the same love for the job as I do now. I think a lot of people feel that way too.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 11:44 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Laurens0404 hat folgendes geschrieben:
I recently discussed the issue with a friend at Airbus and he said that it will be at least another 70 years before there are fully autonomous aircraft flying (and then only extremely few, as it is extremely expensive to insure). In addition, all existing aircraft would have to be converted and taken out of service... So when the first aircraft comes onto the market in 2028, for example, they will be ordered by the airlines (delivery takes
2-5 years) and they will need new training programs, which must be tested first.

In addition, extremely modern aircraft have been developed in the last 5 years, which can easily fly for 30 years.
Conversion would cost the airlines too much money.

The psychological aspect also plays a role; airlines and passengers have safety concerns about completely pilotless aircraft.

In my opinion, and the opinion of the engineer at Arirbus, autonomous aircraft will not fly for the next 60-80 years, or only in very isolated cases. In addition, 1-cockpit crews require an extremely high safety effort.

You can still become a pilot in our generation without hesitation.


It feels good to hear that. Unfortunately, I'm not worried about completely autonomus flight in my lifetime. I think single pilot operations are going to come a lot sooner however. a350 could be by the end of the decade. For the a321, its just another software update. Airbus is also building a next generation plane which they want to release by 2035. Sure, maybe thats too optimistic, but this plane is going to be single pilot capable, and thats from airbus. I think when it does come, a lot of people are not going to enjoy the job as much.

I've spoken to another eu pilot. He said that when a new single pilot airplane is released, airbus can make a lot of money by replacing all boeing fleets, like Ryanair's. They just offer them very heavy discounts for their new single pilot plane, and ryanair sells their 737s one by one - just an example. That, or they could just pay to upgrade their plane to single pilot if physical changes are needed.

I think our only hope is that airlines keep two pilots even though only one is required.

I also feel that in the near future, planes will become over-automated. I think there is a fine line between what is useful, and a level of automation that does too much.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 11:51 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Laurens0404 hat folgendes geschrieben:
I recently discussed the issue with a friend at Airbus and he said that it will be at least another 70 years before there are fully autonomous aircraft flying (and then only extremely few, as it is extremely expensive to insure).


Actually, could you ask your friend at airbus how far away we are from single pilot a321 operations, that could be very useful information. I hope you don't mind.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Laurens0404
Bruchpilot
Bruchpilot


Anmeldungsdatum: 29.10.2024
Beiträge: 5

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 1:29 pm    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

From the Engineer Airbus:

Here are a few facts from the Airbus engineer on the subject. Based on data without sources or exact data. But we should not worry:
1. approval must be granted by EASA, which has not yet been granted. Not even cars or trains can drive autonomously yet, how can airplanes? The influence of labor unions etc. should not be ignored
2. modifications to aircraft: capacities are unimaginable, even the newer models require enormous legal and working time arrangements.
3. at Airbus, all licenses, all supply chains, hangars, personnel, etc. have to be retrained, simply everything that takes an extremely long time. (They are still optimizing the A320, which is 40 Years old) And now we are just at the production stage!
4. how is a new process to be established for each model, experience shows that it takes years to decades...
5. the airplanes are becoming more expensive and require extensive training. On the ground and in the air. Let's assume 22800 registered pilots, if 50% are dropped, there would still be 11400 pilots who have to be retrained and have to hand in new licenses. If you were to retrain the pilots in 24-person classes every 1st week (unlikely), it would take 10 years just to do this.
6. old orders go until 2040. To retire and license these alone... years.
7. society: trust and control are keyfactors.

To summarize: Don't worry, it will take decades before the first planes take off and it will take decades again before they are retrained. And it will take decades again to retire the old ones. All after you retirement.

I think we worry to much, go become a pilot, Smile
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Flerq
NFFler
NFFler


Anmeldungsdatum: 09.12.2024
Beiträge: 16

BeitragVerfasst am: Di Dez 10, 2024 7:22 pm    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Laurens0404 hat folgendes geschrieben:
From the Engineer Airbus:

Here are a few facts from the Airbus engineer on the subject. Based on data without sources or exact data. But we should not worry:
1. approval must be granted by EASA, which has not yet been granted. Not even cars or trains can drive autonomously yet, how can airplanes? The influence of labor unions etc. should not be ignored
2. modifications to aircraft: capacities are unimaginable, even the newer models require enormous legal and working time arrangements.
3. at Airbus, all licenses, all supply chains, hangars, personnel, etc. have to be retrained, simply everything that takes an extremely long time. (They are still optimizing the A320, which is 40 Years old) And now we are just at the production stage!
4. how is a new process to be established for each model, experience shows that it takes years to decades...
5. the airplanes are becoming more expensive and require extensive training. On the ground and in the air. Let's assume 22800 registered pilots, if 50% are dropped, there would still be 11400 pilots who have to be retrained and have to hand in new licenses. If you were to retrain the pilots in 24-person classes every 1st week (unlikely), it would take 10 years just to do this.
6. old orders go until 2040. To retire and license these alone... years.
7. society: trust and control are keyfactors.

To summarize: Don't worry, it will take decades before the first planes take off and it will take decades again before they are retrained. And it will take decades again to retire the old ones. All after you retirement.

I think we worry to much, go become a pilot, Smile


I mostly agree. Planes are much much easier to automate than cars. Think about how much early automation came to aviation then actual self driving. We've had autoland for 60 years. This only works because aviation is highly highly regulated, and hence predictable. We only have to figure out how to deal with non-normal events that don't have checklists.

Also while its true that old orders will go to 2040, these planes can start being delivered with new modifications, or completely new airplanes can come out already single pilot capable. Other than that, I agree with everything. There is probably going to be some time till we reach that point, and unions won't be happy.

It's nice hearing a perspective thats not so doom and gloom, thank you Very Happy
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
E92325
Captain
Captain


Anmeldungsdatum: 26.02.2024
Beiträge: 118

BeitragVerfasst am: Mi Dez 11, 2024 7:59 am    Titel: Antworten mit Zitat

Well, i am working in the automotive industry and self driving regarding autonomous driving is very far away either. There are ambitions and some driving assisstants, which allow partly autonomous driving, but for full autonomous driving. I do not believe in this technology either, among others due to the costs which can be expected for the vehicles, as well as for the infrastructure and also Laurens0404 point 7. society: trust and control are keyfactors.

Regarding to the aviation, he already mentioned the reasons why it wont come to single pilot operation, which i fully agree to. That are sweet dreams of EASA and lobbyists.
Nach oben
Benutzer-Profile anzeigen Private Nachricht senden
Beiträge der letzten Zeit anzeigen:   
   
Neues Thema eröffnen   Neue Antwort erstellen    Pilotenboard.de :: DLR-Test Infos, Ausbildung, Erfahrungsberichte :: operated by SkyTest® :: Foren-Übersicht -> Lufthansa-Ausbildung Alle Zeiten sind GMT + 1 Stunde
Gehe zu Seite Zurück  1, 2, 3  Weiter
Seite 2 von 3

 
Gehe zu:  
Du kannst keine Beiträge in dieses Forum schreiben.
Du kannst auf Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht antworten.
Du kannst deine Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht bearbeiten.
Du kannst deine Beiträge in diesem Forum nicht löschen.
Du kannst an Umfragen in diesem Forum nicht mitmachen.


Impressum        Datenschutzbestimmungen nach DSGVO

Cobalt by Jakob Persson
Cobalt phpBB Theme/Template by Jakob Persson.
Copyright © Jakob Persson 2002.

Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2002 phpBB Group